Rule in question that he broke. Blindsiding an unarmed, unarmored player isn't PvP.

PVP: Only allowed if all parties agree to it. Use chat to make this clear (logs)

As you can see in the screenshot, there is NO conversation of any kind before the attack.

Name:  2014-05-26_14.27.44.png
Views: 49
Size:  531.4 KB